Seven Expensive Investing Mistakes (and the Numbers Behind Them)
The expensive investing mistakes are rarely exotic. Study after study finds the average fund INVESTOR earns meaningfully less than the funds they hold, a behavior gap of roughly one to two percentage points a year in many estimates, produced by ordinary human reactions at the worst moments.
Here are the seven that do most of the damage, with rough numbers attached, because a mistake with a price tag is much easier to refuse. Every figure is approximate and illustrative; the tools exist so you can compute your own.
1. Panic selling in a downturn
The classic and the costliest: selling into a crash converts a temporary drawdown into a permanent loss, and re-entry usually happens well above the exit (see the timing guide's missed-best-days arithmetic). An investor who sold a balanced portfolio near the 2009 or 2020 lows and waited for "clarity" could easily have missed rebounds worth 30% to 60%.
The fix is structural, not motivational: hold an allocation whose historical worst case you have SEEN and accepted (stress test it), so the bad year arrives pre-survived.
2. Chasing last year's winner
Money famously floods into funds, sectors and themes AFTER their best years, which is systematically the wrong direction: winners mean-revert far more often than they repeat. Buying whatever tripled last year is how investors bought tech in 2000 and crypto in 2021: at the top of the chart they were admiring.
The antidote is owning everything cheaply (the index catches the next winner by construction) and letting scheduled rebalancing do the buy-low, sell-high mechanically.
3. Fee blindness
An avoidable 1% annual fee consumes very roughly a sixth of a 30-year outcome (the fees guide walks the math). It is the one mistake on this list with a guaranteed cost and a five-minute fix: read the expense ratios you own and price them in dollars.
4. Concentration you did not choose
Employer stock accumulating through RSUs, one lucky winner outgrowing the portfolio, three funds that secretly hold the same mega-caps: concentration usually happens passively. One stock at 40% of net worth taking an unremarkable 60% single-stock drawdown removes about a quarter of everything (the concentration guide runs the numbers).
Measure it: the correlation tool shows what actually moves together, including positions that look diversified and are not.
5. Waiting in cash for a better moment
Cash awaiting the perfect entry has historically cost more than the corrections it feared: markets spend most of their time at or near highs, and the expected cost of a year on the sidelines exceeds the expected benefit of dodging the average dip. The lump-sum-vs-DCA guide covers the honest middle path when investing a windfall feels impossible.
6. Grading yourself against the wrong number
Comparing a diversified portfolio against a hot index (or a price-only quote) manufactures fake failure and prompts real mistakes: abandoning a sound plan to chase whatever the wrong benchmark did. Judge a portfolio against its own goals on total return, the convention every comparison in these tools uses (the total-return guide explains the trap).
7. Having no written plan at all
Every mistake above gets easier without a plan, because every market event becomes a fresh decision made under stress. A one-page plan (target mix, contribution schedule, rebalancing rule, and what you will do in a 30% drawdown: nothing) converts future panic into procedure.
- •Set the mix from risk capacity, not recent returns (risk profile questionnaire).
- •See the plan's historical worst case before living it (stress test).
- •Automate contributions and rebalancing so discipline does not depend on mood.
- •Review annually, not daily; the portfolio check-in exists for exactly this.
Try it yourself
FAQ
- What is the most common investing mistake?
- Selling during downturns is the most damaging widespread one: it locks in losses and usually misses the rebound. Estimates of the resulting behavior gap commonly run one to two percentage points a year, which compounds into a large lifetime cost.
- What is the behavior gap?
- The difference between a fund's reported return and what its average investor actually earned, created by buying high and selling low around the fund's swings. It is why boring, automated investing frequently beats clever, reactive investing.
- How do I avoid these mistakes?
- Mostly by making fewer live decisions: a written allocation you have stress tested, automatic contributions, scheduled rebalancing, and an annual (not daily) review rhythm. The tools here exist to put numbers behind each of those choices. Educational, not advice.
Key terms in this guide
Plain-English definitions in the Learning Hub.
Stop guessing — run the numbers on your own portfolio, free.
Stress test my plan →More guides
- How to Backtest a Portfolio: A Free, Step-by-Step Guide →
- The 60/40 Portfolio: Returns, Drawdowns, and Whether It Still Works →
- How to Tell If Your Portfolio Is Actually Diversified →
- The 4% Rule, Explained: How Long Will Your Retirement Savings Last? →
- The Efficient Frontier, Explained (Without the Math Headache) →
- Lump Sum vs Dollar-Cost Averaging: What the Data Says →
- Lazy Portfolios, Explained: Simple Index Mixes That Beat Most Investors →
- How Much Do I Need to Retire? A Simple Way to Find Your Number →
- Maximum Drawdown: Why the Worst Loss Matters More Than the Average Return →
- The Sharpe Ratio, Explained: Are You Being Paid for the Risk You Take? →
- Monte Carlo Simulation, Explained: Planning for a Range of Futures →
- Stocks vs Bonds: How They Differ and How to Mix Them →
- How to Read a Stock's Fundamentals (Without an Accounting Degree) →
- Portfolio Rebalancing, Explained: Why and How to Reset Your Mix →
- VOO vs VTI: S&P 500 or Total US Market — Does It Matter? →
- Asset Allocation by Age: How Your Mix Should Change Over Time →
- Index Funds vs ETFs: What's the Difference and Which Should You Pick? →
- Should You Invest Internationally? Home-Country Bias, Explained →
- Dividends vs. Price Growth: Where Your Returns Really Come From →
- Risk Tolerance vs. Risk Capacity: How Much Risk Should You Actually Take? →
- Sequence-of-Returns Risk: Why the Order of Returns Can Make or Break a Retirement →
- Would Your Portfolio Have Survived 2008? How to Stress Test It →
- Factor Investing, Explained: What's Actually Driving Your Returns →
- Real vs. Nominal Returns: Why Inflation Is the Loss You Never See →
- How Much Cash Should You Hold in a Portfolio? →
- How to Invest in the S&P 500 from Canada (VFV, VOO, and Hedging) →
- Currency Risk and Hedging: Should You Hedge Your Foreign Investments? →
- Target-Date Funds Explained: Glide Paths, Fees, and the DIY Alternative →
- Total Return vs. Price Return: Why the Index Chart Understates Reality →
- Expense Ratios Explained: What a 1% Fee Really Costs You →
- Time in the Market vs. Timing the Market: What the Data Says →
- Compound Growth Explained: Why Starting Early Beats Saving More →
- How to Start Investing: A Plain-English Order of Operations →
- Bear Markets: How Deep They Go, How Long They Last, and What Recovers →
- Employer Stock and Single-Stock Concentration: How Much Is Too Much? →
- VEQT vs XEQT: Canada's All-in-One ETFs, Compared →
- RRSP vs TFSA for Investors: How to Think About the Choice →
- Robo-Advisors vs. DIY Index Investing: What the Fee Buys You →
- The Average Stock Market Return (and Why You Almost Never Get It) →